by Charity Erickson
So, Richard Foster and I are fighting.
He doesn’t know this, but we have a long running feud; it has been contentious and bitter and totally one-sided. Ever since everyone and their grandpas started talking about Foster’s Celebration of Discipline, I have been developing a deep-seated resentment against this lovely man and his holy brilliance. “Discipline.” It’s a word I just can’t get over, much less celebrate.
For one already struggling with the old evangelical hero complex, in which I feel the urge to always have to do more, always more, always better, I can’t read Foster without hearing it as something else I’m supposed to add to my already too-long list. And the idea of exerting even more effort in the celebration of something so severe as discipline is dreadful, an extra weight to be hung from an already-too-heavy yoke.
And when there's just so much that's seemingly required, it's overwhelming. My response is to fight against it, or more likely, to just give up. Perhaps I am merely too attached to the lavish comforts of food, drink, and sleep, but it’s much more my style to exercise the spiritual practice of radical self-care, with its promises of holy napping and hearty celebration of chocolate (at least that’s how I do it).
All that said, I decided to put away the bad blood between Brother Richard and myself, and attend his presentation at last week’s Festival of Faith and Writing in Grand Rapids, Michigan. The title of his session sounded mysterious and terribly interesting: “The Humiliation of the Word in our Day.” What could that possibly mean?
And as he began to speak, waxing rhapsodic about the weight and the beauty of words, I shed a tear. The power of creation and Christ are bound up in the Word and words themselves--amen, hallelujah!--also, there is something eminently moving about how that man wears a ponytail. “The Word is precious,” he said. “A word poorly spoken demeans us.”
Respect to my nemesis. That’s some good stuff.
I was so on board. But then discussion turned to how, in our day, the “humiliation” of the written and spoken word is achieved. And while I will take away and hold close what Richard Foster said about the value of words, I feel it behooves me to respectfully disagree with what came after.
As I understand it, he finds the proliferation of words through mass media and digital formats to be enacting a kind of inflation in the value of words, causing even a word well spoken to lose its currency. Not only were formats like Twitter and blogs taken to task for being generally mediocre platforms for meaningful communication (too fast, too easy), visual media was characterized as passive and mindless distraction from the stuff of real value--the written word. Television and film were cast merely as means for “checking out” of reality.
The problem with thinking about new media as a distortion or desecration of the true, written word is that it shows disregard for the fact that all things must be read, not just words. Paintings, faces, numbers, noises, the posture of the body in embrace, a precious Polaroid, clever, cutting hashtags, and even ClipArt. (Is that still a thing? Clearly I’m the last person who should be defending technology.) The language of literature is not the only thing we read. Whenever we take information in and work to make sense of it, this is communication, this is “word,” and all creation cries out.
But how can we understand without one to instruct us? This is the real problem. Not the democratization of media--as if such a thing were possible, even online--the real problem with the polyphony of voices populating the electronic ether is that often we fail to understand them, and too often we don’t want to admit that we don’t know how to read them with discernment. We struggle to process information, evaluate sources, and understand the purpose and potential behind this innovation; it’s a library whose card catalogue is written in secret code. But it’s a code we must decipher; we must learn how to find Dickens amongst the penny-dreadfuls. We must learn how to separate the gold from the dross.
It is not the word but rather we who are humiliated when we are forced to grapple with our own illiteracy, even as children are navigating this cryptic library with such ease. And when I say “we,” I mean those those of us who have had the privilege of being equipped with strategies for reading at a high level--we’ve been educated in the Western canon, an education that has not prepared us to deal with the rebirth of the word in the digital medium. We have our own secret code, but it will not get us passage through the strange, new words set before us.
And I recognize I am preaching to the choir (or more likely, the very hip worship team); most of you who have found your way to this site are not internet noobs. But there are two things I want to say in conclusion: first, when people denigrate new media as mere diversion, don’t settle for that judgment; but also, don’t simply write them off as out-of-touch. So: Richard Foster, you’re okay, brother. Again, this is a new literacy issue; he and others of the same mind might make this judgment in completely good faith because they are simply unaware of the kind and quality of media that can be found outside of established institutions, how to find it, and how to use it.
Second, Christian educators--including internet writers, for writers are educators, after all--have a responsibility to think deeply about new media and how we can open this realm to those unfamiliar to it. We must consider how we can teach the necessary techniques that can lead others to engage it in meaningful ways, and how we can produce the kind of work that makes thoughtful engagement worth the time it takes. The word will not be humiliated in our day as long as we are not content with churning out content; there is new life here, in our digitized selves, waiting for us to give it breath.
So let us not close our eyes, ears, or laptops to the Word, wherever it may be found. Words are intercessors, hanging in the space between bodies and Spirit, and sometimes even the internet groans with longing that keystrokes cannot express. But let us not stay silent; if we shut our screens, perhaps the rocks will cry out.
Charity Erickson and her husband live and work together in the north woods of Minnesota. Check out her blog for more of her writing and follow her on Twitter @CharityJill.
You might also like:
by Amanda Taylor
It’s official; I’m quitting the interwebs.
Well, at least I’m quitting the news, on account of how much I hate it. My cranium aches from the incessant accosting of my poor sweet eyeballs with information about Syria, sumo wrestlers, Miley Cyrus, guns, Grand Theft Auto 5 sales, IPhones, Iran, the IRS, the NSA, Pelini, Miley, Pumpkin Spice lattes, Kardashians, little puppies, shootings, Miley, mental illness, fantasy football, tax evasion and beanie babies (yes, combine those two), Buzzfeed lists, rehab visits, and congressional posturing. I am so tired. And I think more dumber.
This proliferation of information overwhelms the senses and distorts reality, a deluge of chaos so tremendous that anything actually important is either dismissed immediately or covered so extensively that any pertinent details quickly become indistinguishable from the Forrest Gump bubba shrimp monologue. It’s all pineapple shrimp, lemon shrimp, coconut shrimp, pepper shrimp, shrimp stew, shrimp salad…
There was recently a devastating shooting at the Navy Yard in Washington – another shooting, another tragedy, more lives lost. But I already know too much. I know building 197 remains off limits, I know how many times Aaron Alexis cancelled or failed to show for appointments at the VA, how many times he filled or didn’t fill prescriptions, how many people he mentioned hearing voices to. I know he took a Beretta and with “no discernible pattern” wandered around the halls, hunting people, and ultimately murdering 12 innocent men and women.
Maybe I’m off base, but I don’t think I should know every detail of such a gruesome murder by semiautomatic. It’s painful, it’s horrible, and it’s discussed on the same page as low-cal breakfast recipes. I see “Visit the health section for a great low-cal egg-white torta to fight that belly fat!” in the same visual field as “A mother reacts to finding out her son is a cold-blooded murderer.” Wheat torta or Beretta; you choose, they’ll both impact you equally.
TOO much.
To better explain my exodus from the interwebs, here are some of the super important headlines that I came across trying to read the news recently. They are from several of the top news sources in America.
“Kate Moss to go full-frontal in ‘Playboy’” (Finally!)
“Harris says ‘expect no vomiting’ at Emmys” (Forget it, I’m not watching then.)
“How are olives stuffed? Ask USA Today!” (How are olives stuffed? And how have I lived this long without knowing?)
“Injuries on the rise from texting and walking” (I wish I had eyes for my eyes.)
“EVA’s ‘Hello Kitty jets’ take to the runways at LAX” (I just… I can’t… Here: it’s real.)
“Secrets of a Yacht Stewardess” (This turned out to be just a creepy article about a constipated-looking woman in an ascot.)
“Hot ‘Brady Bunch’ Hookups” (Greg and Marcia, Cindy and Bobby, even Jan and Marcia… thanks Fox News for this gem.)
“Pippi Longstocking’ actress Tami Erin changes mind, ready to release X-rated sex tape” (Surprise twist! Yep, this belongs in my sphere of knowledge. For sure.)
I hate how much I know, and how much I don’t know as a result. There are real issues at play that are overshadowed by my superior knowledge of Kate Middleton’s wardrobe. Literally. About three weeks ago I perused 278 photos of the history and present sensation that is her wardrobe. It ate up about two good hours at work. I also read a list about 15 celebrities that you didn’t know were black, learned Christina Aguilera got skinny again, heard Cher dissed Miley (but hate them both enough I managed not to learn details), and in an exciting turn, TJ Maxx is now going to let customers shop online!
I know, too, that the House is gridlocking movement on the most recent Congressional budget approvals in an effort to repeal The Affordable Care Act, but what does that knowledge do for me as an average American citizen? (Ed. Note: This post was written before the government shutdown took effect, hooray for continued gridlock!) What’s the point of having this information about political posturing?
There may be a point – in fact, I think there is, but I’m so lost in my distain for politics and politicians and the congressional genitalia everywhere that I can’t find that role as a citizen. What’s more, I’ve arrived at a place where I don’t want any more information, because none of it feels important, or contextualizes my place in society, or empowers me to participate in the world in a less reactionary way. The onslaught only serves to warp expectations, to assume that we are lifeless blobs waiting for more mindless information about dairy queen managers in Minnesota.
I’ve just finished reading the article about Dairy Queen manager Joey Prusak, tireless hero to our nation’s visually impaired.
I’m quitting the interwebs until further notice.
Amanda Taylor works in “community
development” and no, she doesn’t know what that means either. Forever the
critic. And enthusiast. Never one for dichotomies. Follow her on Twitter @tayloram03 if
you’re not into receiving tweets.
You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology.
You might also like:
by Ben Howard
This week Ben is joined by guest hosts Joanna Bradley and Emily Maynard
to talk about the weird and wild world of Twitter. We'll talk about
meeting internet friends, why you shouldn't date guys from Twitter,
whether or not to self-censor, the ridiculous nature of Twitter fights,
and the awkward moments when the internet and real life merge. Also,
we'll all give our recommendations for Twitter must-follows. Join in,
hang out with us, and have a laugh or two.
If you like the show, please rate and
review us on iTunes. It's the first step in our secret mission to take over the world.
You can download the podcast by clicking here.
Or you can subscribe to the podcast by searching "On Pop Theology" in
the iTunes music store.
Also, remember to "Like" On Pop Theology on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @OnPopTheology for all the updates, posts, and links throughout the week.
Finally, if you'd like to stream the podcast, you can do that here:
Peace,
Ben
If you have any questions, comments, or if you just want to say hi, you can contact us at onpoptheology [at] gmail.com.
You might also like:
by Ben Howard
A year ago today I posted a rambling 300 word post about why it was important to talk about theology and pop culture. Later that day I posted a longer, even more rambling post about the importance of the show Community. I've never read either post in the last calendar year and, to be honest, neither should you. I'm sure they're quite terrible.
Nevertheless, those two posts launched On Pop Theology and today we're celebrating the one year anniversary with our 291st post. Obviously, a lot has happened between then and now. So in celebration of a year of writing I want to share 10 lessons I've learned from my first year of blogging.
10) Writing is therapy.
I've heard this a lot and it's kind of cliche, but it's also entirely true. Over the past year, I've used this space numerous times to process complex and competing emotions. Yesterday's post, where I literally talked to myself, is probably the most obvious example, but I've also worked through issues of identity, tragedy, frustration and anger in posts here. Thank you for indulging me, I hope they helped you too.
9) Famous people are people too.
It's easy to forget that the people on TV and the people in movies and the people who write books and sing songs are actually real people. It's easy to project a lot of emotional baggage onto them and make them "mean" something. I've written about a lot of celebrities, I even had one write back, and it's made me more conscious of the fact that just because someone has a high profile, it doesn't mean they stop being a person.
8) I have no idea what people like.
If you've blogged yourself, you know that it's a rush when one of your posts becomes popular. As a result, the chase for page views can become intoxicating and addictive. I've had periods where I chased popularity and the lesson is I learned is that I have no idea what's actually popular. I've worked hard on posts for days that fall flat, and I've written posts in 20 minutes that explode. I really have no idea why some things are popular and others aren't so I've started to listen to the following advice...
7) Embrace your weird.
My friend John sent me a link to a lecture a few months back. The speaker was talking to a group of video game designers and his advice to them was that instead of searching for popularity or trying to "be creative" they simply needed to embrace their weirdness. This is the advice I've started giving to contributors and it's advice I've tried to heed myself. If you want to write about obscure Austrian poets, do that to the best of your ability. I mean, we spent three days talking about an obscure basketball player and atonement theory last week. Weird is good.
6) It's okay to be wrong.
If I went back and read everything I've written over the past year, I'm sure I'd find some posts that I don't quite agree with anymore. Guess what? That's part of life. Ralph Waldo Emerson once said that "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." A thoughtful, honest inconsistency has allowed me to learn from my mistakes. In one post, someone said they thought I was being racially inconsiderate. I didn't intend to be, but through conversation I made a friend who has lead me to some excellent resources on racial issues that I didn't know before.
5) Don't take yourself too seriously.
Everybody needs to laugh and be silly. Reality can be a rough, messed-up place and sometimes the only appropriate response it to laugh at the absurdity of it all. Certainly, there are times to be serious and humor can be difficult if used in the wrong ways, but we could all use a little more laughter.
4) It's fun to create with friends.
If I had to run this site by myself, I'm pretty sure I would've stopped a few months back. While I love writing and trying to be creative, my favorite aspect of this site is working with my friends to record the podcast and write posts. My favorite memories of the last year have all involved creating things with my friends. If you're one of the 29 blog contributors or one of the 16 voices heard so far on the podcast, thank you, I love you, and you're amazing.
3) You can have real friends on the Internet.
It's crazy I know, but I love how many people I've gotten to know through the blog and Twitter. Nothing beats a good old-fashioned friend in the same city, but Internet friends you're pretty awesome too. I have yet to meet most of you, but hopefully we'll cross paths somewhere along the way. Thanks!
2) The grind is worth it.
Blogging is fun, but it's also a grind. For a while, I would beat myself up if I didn't post for a day or if I missed my deadline (which I am currently in the process of doing), but once I freed myself from my own hang-ups and restrictions a lot of that stress fell away. The grind really is worth it. I can tell my writing has improved, even if it still has a ways to go. I can tell that writing is shaping the way I view the world and is even, I hope, helping me to be a better person. It can be rough and it can be frustrating, but it's worth it.
1) Doubt and vulnerability are more useful than anger.
I've written or outlined a lot of posts while angry or frustrated and I inevitably go back to them when I've calmed down and find myself disappointed in the approach I was planning to take. Righteous indignation can be necessary and trust me, I'm not short of issues that raise my ire, but I've learned that vulnerability and doubt are far more valuable tools for conversation. Righteous indignation may be useful to rally the troops, but it is limited in its strategic usefulness. This is the most important lesson I've learned from blogging and one I want to work on more in the next year. I want to write with more humility and less arrogance, more vulnerability and less rage. I want to write that way because I think it's just a better way to be.
I'd love to hear your favorite memories from the last year, whether you're a contributor or a reader. What have you learned? What do you hope to see in the future?
Peace,
Ben
Ben
Howard is an accidental iconoclast and generally curious individual
living in Nashville, Tennessee. He is also the editor-in-chief of On Pop
Theology and an avid fan of waving at strangers for no reason. You can
follow him on Twitter @BenHoward87.
You might also like: