Showing posts with label morality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label morality. Show all posts

Thursday, November 1, 2012

Sex and The "Biblical" View


Read this book

by Ben Howard


On Tuesday I started reading Rachel Held Evans' new book A Year of Biblical Womanhood. The book is an A.J. Jacobs-like take on the idea of biblical womanhood. For a year, Rachel tries to abide by all of the scriptures relating to women and along the way hilarity and insight ensue.

I'm only three chapters in so far, so this isn't a review, but the book has already sparked a few interesting ideas. In between chapters, Rachel does a profile of a woman from the Bible. The profile between the second and third chapters is Tamar.

If you don't know the story of Tamar, she is the daughter-in-law of Judah. She marries his oldest son, who dies. Then, according to custom, she marries his next oldest son. He also dies. At this point, Judah should marry her to his youngest son, but he refuses. A childless unmarried widower would have been in serious trouble in this society so this refusal is not only a violation of the law, it is also deeply unjust.

Like any proper biblical character, Tamar solves this problem by pretending to be a prostitute and sleeping with Judah, her father-in-law. When the family becomes outraged at Tamar's pregnancy, she reveals to Judah that he is the father and he realizes that he has sinned by not giving her his youngest son.

Yeah, that's a bizarre story. I know. However, note that nowhere is Tamar repudiated for her actions. In fact, she is listed in Jesus' genealogy in Matthew. In fact, the other three women listed (Bathsheba, Ruth, and Rahab), are also involved in relationships that our society would deem illicit. Bathsheba sleeps with David who then kills her husband, Ruth seduces Boaz (check out your Hebrew idioms), and Rahab is a prostitute.

This collection of characters and stories makes me ask a question. Where exactly did we get this puritanical notion of biblical sexual morality? Even the Bathsheba story doesn't condemn sex, it condemns adultery and murder.

Queen Victoria
Now, some will point out that Paul talks an awful lot about sexual immorality and that's certainly true, but is that a response to sex or a response to an overly indulgent culture that expressed sexuality in dehumanizing ways?

I don't want to argue that our present-day cultures overwhelming view of sexuality is correct and that the church should embrace it. In fact, I don't want to endorse anything about our current sexual culture. It's selfish, indulgent, and dehumanizing. People are used for the satisfaction of others. People are consumed.

But at the same time the notion of a biblical view of sexuality seems to have far more in common with Victorian social mores than with anything resembling a truthful and honest reading of the Bible. The Bible talks about sex, but it isn't obsessed with it. It's a biological function and a part of life. You can interpret some books like the Song of Solomon to openly celebrate it.

I think we need to start talking about sex in our culture without acting like its the most titillating topic of conversation. It's part of life, let's treat it that way. Churches need to openly talk about this topic. Families need to openly talk about this topic. Friends need to openly talk about this topic.



Also, we need to crack down on people referencing the "biblical view" of whatever. Bringing the word "biblical" into a conversation about morality or social issues is the equivalent of referencing Hitler or communism in a conversation about politics. It's a bomb intended to disrupt and stop conversation. It's a trump card. Even worse, the person using it is usually wrong. The use of the term biblical ends up denigrating and besmirching the very book that someone is trying to hold so dear.

Biblical family?
Rachel Held Evans conclusion in the book, according to reviews, is that no such thing as biblical womanhood exists. In the gay marriage debate, there are constant references to the biblical or traditional view of marriage. In response, Fred Clark at the blog Slacktivist has started posting his Chick-Fil-A Biblical Family of the Day every Friday to show the diversity and bizarreness of the "biblical" view of marriage and family.


The Bible is a book that tells us about God and how God relates to us and who God is. It is not necessarily a book that tells us about morality. That morality is dictated by our relationship to God and God's character. It is dictated by who God has created us to be and how we are to express that in our context.

We have to interpret things in our world and that's okay. Everything has to be interpreted. The best way to do that is discuss it intentionally in community. It is best to have people tell us why they agree and disagree with what we do and how we can and should improve. It is best to be open to change and growth. 

So let's talk about sex and see where we end up.

Peace,
Ben

You can follow Ben on Twitter @BenHoward87 or email him at benjamin.howard87 [at] gmail.com.

Also, you can subscribe to On Pop Theology via RSS feed or email on the top right corner of the main page.

Monday, August 13, 2012

What Would Dumbledore Do?

on pop theology, philosophy, theology, culture, pop culture, christianity
by Mark Smith
Ever since I stole a battered copy of The Hobbit out of my older brother’s bedroom, I’ve been enamored with fantasy literature. There is a stigma attached to the genre, and while much of it is probably deserved, it has not stopped me from lapping up page after page of swords, dragons, wizards, thieves, and knights.
When it comes to fantasy literature, one of the most common staples is the clear definition of good and evil. The hero is righteous, possibly flawed, but equipped with a sackload of virtues that set him up against a clearly defined villain.
The Harry Potter books follow this exactly. Very early, the reader is told explicitly which wizards are good and which wizards are bad. However, one of the things I love about the Harry Potter series in this regard is that over time this simplicity fades.
While the staple of Harry Good/Voldemort Bad remains intact throughout, there is a smaller ,but much more tangible, battle of good and evil at play within the walls of Hogwarts school. Even if you have not read the books, you are probably aware that the students are sorted into one of four houses by way of a magic hat that magically knows which characteristic best defines the student using...magic psychology or something.
Anyway, the brave go to Gryffindor, the wise go to Ravenclaw, the loyal and hard-working go to Hufflepuff, and the ambitious and cunning go to Slytherin. More importantly, the reader is told, even before all the houses are introduced, that ALL bad wizards come from Slytherin.

Even as a child this bothered me. Why would they teach these students magic? Sitting on one side of the great hall is a table full of future Hitlers and we’re going to train them to blow things up for 7 years? Why not have a magic hat that sorts out the brave, wise, and loyal and tells the devil children to see themselves to the door?

In reality (okay, not reality, but you know what I mean), the idea that all bad wizards are Slytherins is just an over simplification told to a child in a story aimed at children. Over the course of the books as Harry grows older, we learn that the world isn’t quite so black and white. Harry learns that Sirius Black, a wizard wanted for the murder of 13 people, was a Gryffindor. Sure, it turns out that he is actually innocent, but the fact that a hat told everyone he is brave did nothing to stop them from locking him up without trial. Spoiler alert there, sorry.
Later, Harry’s dad, a Gryffindor lauded as a paragon of virtue for the first four books, is revealed to have been a snob and a particularly cruel bully in his younger years. Godric Gryffindor, for whom the house is named, is revealed to have been an oppressor of non-human magical creatures. Some Slytherins are revealed to be good people, like Slughorn and Snape. Oh, spoiler alert on that one, too. I should be more careful.
In church, I fear we often oversimplify the good and evil. Those of us who grew up in church were probably told bedtime stories about God and the Devil, and it all seemed so straightforward in Sunday School. If you do what is right, you are on God’s side. If you do what is wrong, you were on the Satan’s side. However, like Harry, we learn as we get older that things are not always that simple. You can’t tell if a person is good or evil by what colors the stripes on their tie are.
In moments of moral confusion, Harry follows the example of Dumbledore. Dumbledore taught him, in words and actions, that when right and wrong are complicated, love is simple.

As Christians, we follow the example of Jesus. Jesus came to this world at a time when right and wrong were unclear. God’s word had been misinterpreted, and the Pharisees had lost the message behind it. Jesus delivered that message, and the message from Rabbi to Pharisee was similar to the one from Harry’s wise headmaster. When the law is complicated, the most important thing is to love God. The second most important thing is to love each other.

I don’t need to tell anyone what the topics of moral ambiguity are in the world today, and I’m certainly not going to tell you what you should believe about any particular one. I will say that the more I try to see both sides of any issue and the more I see the motivations of the people behind them, I, like Harry, start to lose my sense of what right and wrong really mean. 

 
Those who followed Dumbledore often disagreed about what his intentions would have been, just like those who follow Christ disagree. The best advice I can offer is this: When life is at its peak of frustrating moral ambiguity, the best thing to do is follow Harry’s lead and make the decision that shows love.


Friday, July 6, 2012

The Serenity of Good Without God

on pop theology, philosophy, theology, culture, pop culture, christianity
Today I'm posting an anonymous guest post.  Many of you won't agree with portions of this post, and well, that's kind of the point.  To have a truly vibrant and helpful discussion we must all be open to views that push and prod at our understanding of the world.  I hope you enjoy and I'd love to hear any feedback you have.

Peace,
Ben
----------------------
by Anonymous 
For the unindoctrinated, the TV show Firefly and the subsequent film, Serenity, follow Captain Malcom Reynolds (pictured) and his crew in a Wild West-esque future. The story takes place across multiple worlds as the crew of the ship Serenity pirates around a solar system occupied by humans after the “Earth-That-Was” could no longer support its population. 

Another note for the unindoctrinated, stop being dumb and go watch every disc right now and don’t talk to me again until you do! angry sound effects
 

For the rest of you, “Hello and welcome. Please continue.”
 

Captain Malcom Reynolds goes by “Mal,” which is, as series discusses, the root word of the Latin “malum” and “malus,” meaning ill, bad, harmful, evil, and wicked, as well as “maleficium,” meaning wrong-doing, harm, injury and mischief. It is also made clear throughout the series that Mal doesn’t believe in god, or more accurately, he doesn’t believe anymore.
 

With those facts in mind, someone who hasn’t seen the series (Which is no one, right? I thought I was very clear back there) would conclude Mal is an interplanetary Jesse James. In fact, Mal is closer to an unintentional vigilante. A measured, moral, dashing vigilante.
 

To be fair (read: to avoid angry, counter arguments), Mal commits his share of immoral acts. He fights. He steals. He even kills, though usually not as a first option. 

But the core of the character is good. He acts, often at his own peril, in the interest of his crew, his friends, strangers in need, and the human race as a whole. A few proof points:
  • He steals a shipment heading to an outpost on a border world, but when he discovers the contractor who gave him the job didn’t tell him everything, namely that the shipment is medicine and the outpost will be in dire straits without it, he returns it to local officials and accepts the wrath of the sadistic contractor.
  • Years before the TV episodes and movie take place, Mal volunteers for the Independentce army which fights to stay separate from Alliance governance. He does this because of his belief in the peoples right to live their lives freely and not be subject to the will of others’ ideals.
  • He refuses to kill a man in a dual that was forced upon him stating, “Mercy is the mark of a great man.” (Of course, Mal then gives the other man two small, nonfatal stabs and acknowledges maybe he’s just, “Alright.”)
  • Most notably, (Spoiler Alert: This is the entire plot of the movie Serenity.) he goes to extreme lengths to broadcast a video that reveals the heinous outcome of a underhanded attempted by the Alliance to control an entire world through forced medication. Mal is willing to sacrifice his life in order to right a wrong decades past.
He operates without a God-pointing moral compass, yet has a steadfast moral code that can be summarized as: Love and protect those who earn it and need it, no matter the cost. For everyone else, an equal and opposite reaction to their evil action. 

Mal is good without God. No, he doesn’t turn his cheek. He doesn’t spoon out soup to the homeless. He sure as hell isn’t meek. And he does have his shortcomings, which he recognizes, but he preserves his freedom, and that of his crew, and navigates lawless worlds without leaving a swath of destruction and, in most cases, leaves things slightly better. 

Who could ask for more? Isn’t that every good person’s aim? Deal the best you can with the world around you, leave it better than you found it, all while making those around you happier. 

Mal is an example of the current atheist rallying cry, “Good without God.” The series also gives many examples of people who are bad without Satan— mal sine diabolus—as well as good with God and bad with God. 

“Good without God” is a plea for people to see that the guidance of a deity isn’t required for good behavior. In my experience—and I imagine yours, if you’re honest—the moral atheist (or at least, nonreligious)/bad atheist ratio is the same as the moral religious/bad religious ratio. 

Atheists are viewed by many (dare I say, most) people as bad. Perhaps not always out loud, but as a gut feeling. The most commonly expressed thought is: Atheists don’t believe in God so they can act as they wish.   

However, almost universally, atheists view their non-belief in God separate from their views on appropriate behavior.

This atheist finds deep serenity in the fact that there is a sense of morality separate of religion. It doesn’t take knowledge of a God in order for a person to know good from bad. People across the Earth-That-Is, regardless of their experience know to protect those who have earned it and need it and correct those who don’t. 

Like Mal, I think it is vital to see people for who and what they are—and what they are is conveyed by what they do. He deals with priests, high society, and outlaws and holds them to the same standard. What they believe or the moral code they claim to subscribe to holds no bearing on the actual world, so it is of no consequence to him or anything else. 

What is of consequence is how they, and you, change the world.

(Unlike Mal, I am not so confident in my relationships and surroundings, so I will sign this post…)
 

- Anonymous Atheist