Showing posts with label Doctor Who. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Doctor Who. Show all posts

Thursday, May 8, 2014

The Problem of Evil: Devils, Aliens and Doctor Who

by Laura Brekke

A word of preface: this blog contains spoilers about episodes in Season 2 Doctor Who. If you haven’t seen them yet – get thee to a TV and watch first!

Cultures across human history have struggled with the problem of evil. From vindictive gods who must be appeased, to hoards of supernatural demons tempting the unwary away from the righteous path, evil is the topic of much mythical and theological deliberation. The persistence and origin of evil, particularly in the post-Enlightenment era, continues to perplex theologians and philosophers alike. And, so too, the wrestling with this problem of evil continues as well, and is taken up by the science fiction cult phenomenon Doctor Who.

In the pair of episodes from season 2, “The Impossible Planet” and “The Satan Pit,” the Tenth Doctor and his companion Rose, encounter a planet somehow suspended just within the reach of a black hole. A legend tells that this black hole had once swallowed the planet up, but then spit it out again, giving rise to the planet’s name “The Bitter Pill.” Upon this impossible planet, the Doctor and Rose encounter a crew of scientists, drilling to the center and looking for the source of incomparable energy which is radiating out across the universe from the planet’s center and somehow keeping it from being swallowed again1.

After the station is rocked by several earthquakes, the crew is plagued by a series of violent possessions, and the Doctor discovers a malevolent alien chained at the planet’s core. The alien, a great, horned beast chained in a pit of fire, confirms to the Doctor that he is the root of every mythic devil-figure in every culture across the universe. Imprisoned in the planet’s core, the beast uses telepathy to transmit the concept of embodied evil across the stars, possessing crew member Toby in a bid to escape his pre-historic prison. Of course the Doctor, in his brilliant, whimsical way, is able to defeat the alien monster by plunging the planet into the black hole. The Doctor swoops in on the TARDIS just in time to rescue the remaining members of the crew and his beloved companion Rose, before whisking them away from the yawning mouth of the black hole’s abyss. Cue the Doctor Who closing theme.

Well, then. What does this have to say about the problem of evil? Rather a lot, actually.

For starters, we have to remember that at this point, Russell T Davies was the head writer, and an ardent and vocal atheist. He was clear in several episodes that he was challenging long-accepted religious (particularly Christian) tenets. In “The Satan Pit,” the Doctor gives a monologue in which he asserts that there are no true “gods” as such:

DOCTOR: So that’s the trap. Or the test, or final judgment, I don’t know. But if I kill you, I kill her. Except that implies in this big grand scheme of Gods and Devils that she’s a victim. But I’ve seen a lot of the universe. I’ve seen fake gods and bad gods and demi-gods and would-be gods, and out of all of that whole pantheon, if I believe in one thing, just one thing, I believe in her.

In his monologue, the Doctor declares that there are no true gods – not in the sense of any ultimate Creator or all-knowing deity. There are only false impressions of would-be deity impersonators in a world governed by science. In fact, when the Beast claims to have been imprisoned before the universe began – before time itself – the Doctor rejects his claim for it defies his truth of science and reason. “Is this your religion?” the Beast asks the Doctor, who responds with, “It’s a belief.”

The back and forth between the Beast, the origin of much great evil, and the Doctor, who is characterized by ultimate good (although, those of you who follow the show know that it is a shadowy sort of good, marked by imperfections) asserts 2 points: 

1. there are no universal religious truths, insofar as even science can be categorized as religion (there are only beliefs)

2. that evil is real, and the representations of supernatural evil in every mythic incarnation are the result of an ancient alien being chained in the heart of a planet suspended in orbit around a black hole.

There is no intentional “God.” But supernatural evil can be pinned to the first cause, a brutal, power-hungry, violent Satan-like telepathic monster. The show doesn’t posit that all evil is a result of this ancient alien. Episodes like “Rise of the Cybermen” and “Age of Steel” (also Season 2), are parables of how human weakness and greed lead to acts of incomprehensible evil (the slaughter of thousands of innocent victims in order to create an army of Cybermen).

But the show does make the claim that the eerily similar stories of a powerful supernatural evil – an evil which has the power to manipulate individuals into choosing the bad, giving into the pressures of fear, and causing general discord between people – is real and can be attributed to an ancient telepathic beast.

This seems almost laughable. For a show which has gone out of its way to create a god-free universe, to challenge notions of the supernatural, and to dismantle the power of myth, it seems like a weak way-out to simply exchange the idea of a fallen angel for an imprisoned telepathic alien. But precisely because such a show does not turn to “rational science” to explain away evil, we are confronted with just how complex the problem of evil still remains.

Just as theologians have tried to make sense of how radical evil2 can exist in a world that Christians affirm was created good by a loving God, so too, these non-theist characters are trying to navigate how inexplicable, radical evil can exist in a world governed by science and the triumph of reason. Radical evil just doesn’t compute. St. Augustine believed fully that radical evil was the result of Satan, a fallen angel, who manipulated humans into terrifying acts. Karl Barth argued that evil, real evil, is actually nothingness (das Nichtige) which comes as the result of doing the opposite of God’s will. And, Process Theology wrestles with the theodicy question by limiting God’s power and saying that, “Yes, God is good, but God is not Almighty, and therefore evil is a result of human error without a divine corrective (because correction would be coercion).”

Ultimately, the problem and mystery of evil isn’t adequately explained by philosophers, theologians, or even the good Doctor himself. It’s hard to believe that any human being can become so sin-warped that he would entertain the idea of burning people in ovens; and yet, we are nevertheless faced with the grotesque horrors of the Holocaust. People report demon possession every year, and it manifests in ways which science can’t always ascribe to recorded forms of mental illness. We have biological fears of the dark; and we have biological fears, in many ways, of ourselves, fears which can be manipulated and result in great harm.

The problem of evil – of radical inexplicable evil – is a perennial one. By attributing supernatural evil (or influence to choose evil) to a prehistoric, telepathic alien monster imprisoned within a planet suspended in orbit around a black hole at the far reaches of the universe, Doctor Who is saying (like most theologians have said): we don’t really know. Why not an ancient telepathic alien? It makes as much sense as a fallen angel (which is to say, none).

Radical evil is precisely non-sensible.  It doesn’t make sense. And while we try to wrestle with it, to find its’ first cause instead of just living with its unholy effects, we are left with philosophical wanking, and ancient myth. Truthfully, no one really knows where and why there is radical evil. But one thing is certain, it exists – even the Doctor accepts the fact that it exists. What becomes the issue worth spending a lifetime unpacking is this: what will we do, you and I, in the face of it? 

1. I want to say that the curiosity of the human scientists is, in itself, worth discussing. But, that would be a digression from the topic of evil, so I’ll save it for another day!↩  
2. I am making the distinction between “natural evil” – like a monsoon or cancer, which is the unfortunate result of a natural process – and “moral evil” – the evil as a result of human choices. When I say “radical evil” I am talking about the seemingly inhuman ways in which human beings create/perpetuate evil. The horrors of the Holocaust, or the Cambodia Killing fields are two examples of radical evil.↩

Laura Brekke is a woman of many names and many interests. When she is being a grown up, she directs Religious Diversity as a Catholic university in California. When she is being an academic, she ponders theological anthropology and popular culture. When she’s being a pastor, she writes a blog musing about faith, spirituality, and our reluctance to be vulnerable. And when she is just being herself, she proudly embraced her inner Whovian fangirl.

You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology. If you'd like to support what we do here, you can donate via the button on the right of the screen.

Image Credits:
Image #1

Image #2 
Image #3
  
You might also like:  

Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Christmas Magic, Miracles, and Doctor Who

art, installation, no miracles here, belief, doubt
Image by Mot
by Ben Howard 

I don’t believe in miracles. As a matter of faith I confess to believing in a few, the virgin birth, the resurrection, even the occasional healing, but they aren’t the cornerstones of my faith. If you adamantly argued that they were physically impossible and never happened, I wouldn’t try and fight you. The theological implications of these miracles are more than enough to overwhelm any question of historicity.

That is to say, do not take this confession as an endorsement of skepticism, even though I am a skeptic. While I may not believe in the miraculous, I would very much like to. It strikes me as a much more optimistic way to encounter the world; a world full of indescribable and undiscoverable mysteries and wonders. I would very much like to live in a world where epic, magnificent, magical things occur, whether rarely or as a matter of course.

But, much to my consternation, I have a difficult time believing that this world of miracles is the same as the one where I live, where the rules of physical reality seem to hold fast.

This tension, between my natural skepticism and my desired belief, makes me especially vulnerable at this time of year to the mystical sentimentality of Christmas specials. There's  a certain magic in a cold, dark, snowy night when everyone is warm in their homes while wondrous adventures are unfolding in the world around them without their knowledge and I easily suspend my disbelief for an hour or two to lose myself in the story.

In recent years, I've found myself enthralled by the traditional Christmas specials of the British sci-fi series Doctor Who. These episodes combine the typical Christmas tropes I find so wonderfully appealing, such as wintery nights in Dickensian England, with the utter insanity of a alien time-traveler on a constant quest to save the world. Also he wears a bowtie because bowties are cool.
doctor who, tardis, christmas specials, clara oswald, snowmen
Image by Slytan

I find The Doctor's Christmas specials especially affecting because they present such a complex and enticing alternate reality. Not only do they include the ineffable “Christmas magic,” they also include the presence of the otherworldly. The mere presence of The Doctor, a Time-Lord from the planet Gallifrey, points beyond himself to the existence of infinitely more worlds with infinitely more wonders to explore.

When contrasted with my own skepticism, the “Christmas magic” becomes just as otherworldly, just as foreign and impossible as the fantastical notion of a madman in a blue box traveling through space and time. Yet I still find myself entranced by a glimpse of this world. While I do not believe that such a thing exists, whether it be Christmas miracles or time-traveling spacemen, I very much wish that it did and by the simple act of engaging in it the gates of my mind are held open to the possibility, even if just a crack, that there is a bit of magic in the world.

I want to believe in miracles. I want to believe in them so hard that maybe they’ll even come true.

Ben Howard is an accidental iconoclast and generally curious individual living in Nashville, Tennessee. He is also the editor-in-chief of On Pop Theology and an avid fan of waving at strangers for no reason. You can follow him on Twitter @BenHoward87.  

You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology. If you'd like to support what we do, you can donate via the button on the right of the screen.
  
You might also like:  

Sunday, June 2, 2013

On Pop Theology Podcast: Episode 25 - Sad Is Just Happy For Deep People

by Ben Howard

Ben, Sebastian, Jesse and Ryan talk about the manufactured happiness of churches from the "Too Blessed to be stressed" mindset to having all songs played in a major key. We talk about why Ben has a hard time being happy on Ash Wednesday, the importance of liturgical traditions, and how Scrubs can teach us about balancing joy and pain. Also, Jesse and Ben trade Anne of Green Gables and Doctor Who references to explain their points as true nerds are wont to do. Join in and enjoy as we talk about how the church can be both happy and sad as it attempts to embrace the reality of everyday life.

You can download the podcast by clicking here. Or you can subscribe to the podcast by searching "On Pop Theology" in the iTunes music store. If you download the show through iTunes, please be so kind as to rate and review us. We want your feedback and it helps the show to grow.

Also, remember to "Like" On Pop Theology on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @OnPopTheology for all the updates, posts, and links throughout the week.

Finally, if you'd like to stream the podcast, you can do that here:


Peace,
Ben

If you have any questions, comments, or if you just want to say hi, you can contact us at onpoptheology [at] gmail.com.

You might also like:   

Sunday, May 5, 2013

On Pop Theology Podcast: Episode 21 - Doctor Who, The Hunger Games and God w/ Julie Clawson

by Ben Howard

Ben and co-host Mark Smith talk with Julie Clawson, author of The Hunger Games and the Gospel, about Doctor Who, the Hunger Games trilogy, and how they relate to the the Christian life. Join in as they discuss the relational nature of both the Doctor and the Hunger Games as well as the way both narratives deal with violence and pacifism.

Be sure to check out Julie's blog One Hand Clapping, her books on Amazon, and follow her on Twitter @julieclawson.

You can download the podcast by clicking here. Or you can subscribe to the podcast by searching "On Pop Theology" in the iTunes music store. If you download the show through iTunes, please be so kind as to rate and review us. We want your feedback and it helps the show to grow. 
 
Also, remember to "Like" On Pop Theology on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @OnPopTheology for all the updates, posts, and links throughout the week.

Finally, if you'd like to stream the podcast, you can do that here:


Peace,
Ben

If you have any questions, comments, or if you just want to say hi, you can contact us at onpoptheology [at] gmail.com.

You might also like:   

Monday, April 22, 2013

On Pop Theology Podcast: Episode 19 - God and Doctor Who w/ James McGrath

by Ben Howard

Ben and Jesse sit down with Dr. James McGrath, religion professor at Butler University and author of the blog Exploring Our Matrix, to talk about the geeky wonderfulness that is Doctor Who and why the show interacts with religion. Join us as we talk about Time Lords, companions, and the philosophical importance of TV's longest running show.

Be sure to check out James' blog Exploring Our Matrix and follow him on Twitter @ReligionProf.

You can download the podcast by clicking here. Or you can subscribe to the podcast by searching "On Pop Theology" in the iTunes music store. If you download the show through iTunes, please be so kind as to rate and review us. We want your feedback and it helps the show to grow. 
 

Also, remember to "Like" On Pop Theology on Facebook and follow us on Twitter @OnPopTheology for all the updates, posts, and links throughout the week.

Finally, if you'd like to stream the podcast, you can do that here:


Peace,
Ben

If you have any questions, comments, or if you just want to say hi, you can contact us at onpoptheology [at] gmail.com.

You might also like: 

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Rule Number 1: Your Faith Lies

Doctor Who, Matt Smith, Doctor Liesby Ben Howard

I only started watching Doctor Who about a month ago. Depending on your position on the nerdcore scale this is either totally meaningless or an egregious error in judgment that possibly puts into question whether you can ever trust me again.

Now, I'm not thoroughly indoctrinated (see what I did there) into the mythology of the show since I've only watched the most recent three seasons and a handful of earlier episodes. However, even in that small amount some of the larger themes have definitely caught my eye. The Doctor's refusal to use violence is almost prophetic in the way it speaks into our cultures obsession with force and bloodshed. I also love the way the Doctor is both playful and profoundly sad thus showcasing the fact that silliness is not disconnected from seriousness.

There are tons of examples of wonderful truths being spoken and explored by this show, but the most fascinating aspect of the show that I've encountered so far is also a very simple one.

In fact, it's rule number one: the Doctor lies.

At this point in my life it's almost impossible to watch or read anything without immediately making theological comparisons. I mean, I've probably got a thousand words rattling around somewhere about how Alex Trebek is like an all-knowing God or how Wipeout is an apt depiction of the Christian walk. However, watching Doctor Who is something much more profound than that, it's more like watching the first Superman movie; it's almost begging you to compare the hero to Christ.

Amy, Rory, Doctor WhoBefore you ask, no, I am not about to say that Jesus lies. At least, not quite. It’s more interesting than that.

Rule number one comes up on the show so consistently because the Doctor’s companions have to be constantly reminded. Even though they know the truth, even though they’ve been told over and over again that the Doctor lies, they still believe him. They have faith in him.

The Doctor always saves them, always comes back for them, always makes sure that the good guys win and the bad guys lose and the, and since they believe him to be so trustworthy, they are blinded to the fact that he isn’t always truthful. Their faith, their honest, earnest and defensible faith deceives them about reality.

The Doctor tells his companions and friends that he lies, yet they believe him with unquestioning faith anyways.

I think that’s what God and Doctor Who have in common. Followers so full of faith that it can drown out the sounds of reality, so full of faith that it drown out the lessons they’ve been told over and over again about who they’re really following and how wild and unrestrained by rules he really is.

This is far from a call to stop believing, that’s impossible. Everyone has beliefs, and of course they think they’re beliefs are true, otherwise they’d get new ones. No, this is a statement about the certainty of our faith. While our faith is valid and good, that certainty is an illusion. Our faith lies.

Rule #1, number one, rule, the doctor lies, Doctor Who, TardisSometimes the things we whole-heartedly believe turn out to be wrong and that’s an incredibly difficult thing to admit. When our faith leads us astray, when our faith lies to us about the reality that actually exist, we look everywhere else for answers. We blame our parents, the church we grew up in, we blame God for not being the God we originally believed in. It’s hard to bear the tension that comes with a faith that can only ever be incomplete and fallible.

Our perception of God, Jesus, and he Holy Spirit is always, in some ways, a lie. It is always wrong. Whether it’s off only a little or a lot, the certainty that comes with faith is always an illusion.

So perhaps the real comparison isn't between Doctor Who and God, or Doctor Who and Jesus, but between Doctor Who and our constructs of God and Jesus. The reality of God and Jesus evade us, they’re complexity is something far beyond us. Remember, it says in Isaiah, “Your thoughts are not my thoughts and your ways are not my ways.”

These constructs are our creations. They come from our families, our traditions, our experiences,our fears, and our desires. They are valuable and beautiful and necessary.

But remember rule number one, they lie.

Peace,
Ben

Ben Howard is an accidental iconoclast (see!) and generally curious individual living in Nashville, Tennessee. He is also the editor-in-chief of On Pop Theology and an avid fan of waving at strangers for no reason. You can follow him on Twitter @BenHoward87.

You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology.

You might also like: