Showing posts with label friendship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label friendship. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 16, 2014

Because I Know You: Friendship and Tom Cruise

by Charity Erickson

The other day, I went to see Edge of Tomorrow, the newest addition to Tom Cruise’s rather extensive sci-fi repertoire. I entered the theater not knowing much about the film, and to my amusement, I found it follows the same basic plot of Groundhog Day--with an alien invasion as the backdrop. (Google confirms that I am approximately the 416,000th person to make this observation.)

The similarities are uncanny: in Groundhog Day, Bill Murray’s Phil Connors relives the same day over and over until he figures out how to love selflessly. In Edge of Tomorrow, Tom Cruise’s William Cage is a military propagandist who finds himself able to reset the same day over and over as he attempts to defeat the time-manipulating collective consciousness of an alien horde that besets humanity. Also, there is a woman!

Each day that Cage resets--which he does by dying--he must find this woman, a soldier wunderkind named Rita, and together they try (and fail) each time to defeat their indomitable foe. Upon failing, Cage kills himself. And then, *respawn*. However, Cage is the only one able to remember and learn from all of their failed attempts to save the world; for Rita, each day she meets Cage is the first.

While the film is pretty meh in the inventiveness of its hero’s arc (even with the whole time travel thing, the film’s action unfolds in a staid and predictable fashion,) the relationship between Rita and Cage saves this piece of science fiction. Really good science fiction, in the end, is not simply speculation about other worlds, realities, futures and pasts; it uses that which is fictive and far away to talk about things that are close: love, war, fear, family. In the case of Edge of Tomorrow, amidst exploding aircraft and vicious aliens, we find a rather poignant statement on what makes a friendship.

Toward the end of the film, Rita expresses frustration with Cage that he is unwilling to sacrifice her life in order to complete their mission and end the war. In her reality, they’ve only just met; yet in Cage’s reality, they have spent the equivalent of years together. She asks him why he cares whether she lives or dies, and he answers, as though it should be self-evident: “Because I know you.” Not “Because I love you,” or “Because I need you,” but simply because he knows her. There is something terribly beautiful about the simplicity of his statement: all it takes to deeply care about another person is to take the time to know her.*

Through the vast majority of the film, the relationship between Rita and Cage reads as a completely platonic, even one-sided friendship, and I find this fascinating as it is not a topic often explored in “serious” film; it is a topic most often relegated to comedy and chick flicks. (The only opposite-gender friendships I can think of in popular media are found in sitcoms--Liz Lemon and Jack Donaghy being the most touching example, obvs.) The “bromance” has made the topic of male friendship more common in film, but somewhat-problematically so. Not only does the term whiff of giggling, “no homo” douchebaggery, but it also demonstrates that we are still so ill at ease when speaking about deep friendship, we can’t even figure out a word to call it that doesn’t confusingly conflate it with eros.

That said, I am happy that films exploring the importance of friendship are being made. Anything that acknowledges and normalizes the role deep friendships play in our lives is a boon to the emotional life of our culture, a guide to better and healthier relationships. When we don’t take friendship seriously in art and media, when we leave it unacknowledged as a source both of joy and pain in life, we do a disservice to the richness to be found in meaningful relationships that are founded neither on kinship nor sexual attraction.

For just as we are interdependent with other people, we are interdependent with our media--we trust it to hold a mirror to humanity, and we inform it, just as it informs us. When media portrays the love among friends as trivial compared to, say, romantic love, that attitude leaches into our lived lives, and we find ourselves either confused by the powerful emotions of friendship or we deprive ourselves of those relationships from the start. Like Edge of Tomorrow, perhaps more films will think deeply about the sanctity of friendship and usher in a future where our definitions of love are bigger. Tom-Cruise-summer-blockbuster-sized, even. Amen.

*Spoiler/Caveat: the film hinted at romance at the VERY end, but I chose to ignore it. BECAUSE IT MADE NO SENSE. And apparently, no such romantic relationship exists in the graphic novel upon which the film is based--which must be why the intimation here seemed so out-of-place. 


Charity Erickson and her husband live and work together in the north woods of Minnesota. Check out her blog for more of her writing and follow her on Twitter @ecumystic.

You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology. If you'd like to support what we do, you can donate via the button on the right of the screen.

You might also like:

Friday, February 14, 2014

The Value In All Sorts Of Loves

by Emily Maynard
 
If you’ve walked into any store that sells things recently, you may have noticed that love is in the air. Actually, it’s on the shelves, the display tables, the aisles, the walls, and piled next to the checkout counter.

Ever since they slid the Christmas lights into the clearance bin the first week of January, we’ve been overrun with heart-shaped confetti and chocolates and sentimental statements screen-printed onto everything. In fact, today might be a bit of a relief, because it’s nearly over now. And it’s almost time for Shamrock Shakes, but I digress.

It’s fine with me if you’re not really into Valentine’s Day this year. I get that. Valentine’s Day is kitschy and overdone and maybe it makes you barf in your mouth a little when couples get super into it on social media.

It seems like torture, when it’s already the coldest and most miserable time of year, for all the privileged, partnered people to have a day set aside to gloat.

It’s like a giant stuffed bear holding a heart that says you’re a loser if you don’t have a certain type of love in your life, and it can be incredibly painful. Some of you probably have stories about romances that feel more like cruel April Fool’s Day jokes.

I’ve been there, too.

This year, though, I am told that everything is supposed to be different. I’ve captured that mythical unicorn of every Young Christian Woman’s heart: a real, live, authentic human boyfriend. All the commercials, and even some of the messages I’ve heard at church, tell me that I should throw myself into romance at the expense of all else. They say I should expect to be showered with diamonds, or at least confetti and chocolate, as a memorial of our love. One of my friends even made mention of it recently when we were trying to make plans to hang out, “Oh, well, next weekend is Valentine’s Day, so you’ll be busy, of course.”

Everything is expected to change now that I’m “in a relationship,” but the thing is, I’ve been in real, significant relationships with people for years before now. It’s called friendship.

It didn’t even occur to me that I’d spend Valentine’s Day with only one person this year, considering I’ve spent so many February-14ths romantically unattached. I’ve formed other habits, and I’m not giving up my independence or my affections for the people that matter in my life.

I missed the rule that years of friendship don’t count once you find a quality mouth-kissing partner. So, this year, like so many years before, I’ll be celebrating Cupid’s birthday with my friends.

My friends and I have relationships that have flourished for years, and that’s without the added incentive of smooching hormones. They’re the ones who loved me when I was wearing cargo overalls (1997), plucking my eyebrows into oblivion (2003), and hadn’t yet discovered dry shampoo or feminism, but definitely needed both (1999-2012). They have shared adventures, ideas, empathy, happiness, and hope through many heartaches. They are the people who have shaped me into who I am and showed me what faithfulness, equality, and love really look like every day. And they have my undying affection in return.

Our culture celebrates romance above all other expressions, but I think friendship actually deserves the biggest cozy-stuffed-animal-holding-a-heart pillow of them all.

If you’ll permit me to rearrange your social life, please, pull back the kitsch and the mushiness and commercialism, and go have an amazing Valentine’s Day with your friends. Not because you’re cynical about the state of romance in the world, but because you see the value in all sorts of loves.

Shower your friends with confetti and chocolates, not because friendship is second best and it’ll suffice until you meet The One, but because love is not limited to one particular type of relationship.

Find ways to celebrate the relationships that tough out years of commitment even without the added sexual chemistry. 

Emily Maynard is an outgoing introvert from Portland, Oregon. She is a big picture thinker and big question ask-er. She likes Twitter, vegetables, fashion, Harry Potter, mentoring college students, new information on anything, and declarative sentences. Emily does her thinking aloud at Emily Is Speaking Up and @emelina.  

You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology. If you'd like to support what we do, you can donate via the button on the right of the screen.
 

Image Credits:
Image #1 via J. Girard 
Image #2 via Sister72 
Image #3 via Lunchtimemama
  
You might also like:  

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Confessions of a Hopeless Romantic: The Bachelorette and Online Dating

ABC, The Bachelorette, competitive dating, TV, reality, love


by Ben Howard

I don't watch the Bachelor or the Bachelorette with any regularity, but that doesn't stop me from enjoying the show when I do. In my defense, I love sports and the sport of competitive dating is no different. But I also love fairy tales and the Bachelor/ette is, at its core, a fairy tale. It's a fictional story of people who fall in love in a magical land and live happily ever after. The show ends happily ever after; pay no attention to the broken engagement behind the curtain.

I've always been a hopeless romantic at heart, so I often give myself over to fairy tale daydreams of love. I don't just want love and a wife, I want a story, and a good one at that. I want one of those stories that you tell your kids for like eight years and becomes the basis for a hit sitcom on CBS. Simple enough, right?

But there's another side to me that's deeply rational and a bit cynical. This is the side that is over fairy tales and the artistic machinations of love. This is the side that talks me into signing up for dating websites.

Everybody has a dating website. JDate if you're Jewish. Christian Mingle if you're a Christian. OKCupid if you're poor and/or bored with normal humans. Personally, after a fair amount of internet dating experimentation, I've settled on eHarmony. It's like dating, but with more math and less of that messy personal interaction.


Captivating, John Eldredge, no, women, book, eHarmonySeriously, it's fantastic. You can work through a list of potential matches to see which one's short answer writing style sets your heart aflutter. Personally, I weed out all matches that set off personal pet peeve alarms. This includes anyone who says they read Captivating or Twilight unironically as well as anyone who refers to God with capitalized pronouns (unless they were feminine pronouns, then I might be intrigued).

I've even re-worked my own profile multiple times. I've written it serious and straight-forward, manic and ridiculous, gentle and sweet, and, most recently, semi-honestly. I use the best picture I've ever taken as my profile picture, even though it's more than two years old and it only shows half my face. I just really want people to see the best version of me, which coincidentally, is only tangentially related to who I really am.

This is insane. This is ridiculous. This is real life.
Sometimes I'll joke that I really want to start a relationship six months in, or better yet, like six years in. I want to be comfortable and vulnerable with the other person now. I want to trust them now. I want them to understand my weird quirks and my occasionally bizarre anti-social behavior now. I want to be known, but I don't want to go through that messy, awkward process of letting someone get to know me.

I'm caught in this trap, really we all are, between who I am and who I'd like you to think I am. The first is comfortable for me, but I'm scared you won't like it. The second one causes me deep anxiety, but I enjoy the affirmation.

Though this seems disingenuous, I'm not certain that it is. Maybe we have to let people get to know our somewhat artificial, definitely superficial selves before they can get to know the beautiful/frightening person on the inside.

love, flower, friendship, weird, amazon.com, chinese dollI've had friendships that were birthed out of emotional difficulty. They are wonderful and I love these friends very much, but there is a problem. It's hard to be normal friends with them, it's hard to just hang out. We can talk about life and death and pain and suffering and I know things about them and they know things about me that I wouldn't share with another soul, but a normal conversation sometimes eludes us.

I don't think we earn the really valuable, long-lasting relationships we crave unless we go through the mess and anxiety of learning about each other slowly, over time. I think we need the often frustrating path towards trust and friendship and love. We don't need a fairy tale, because they aren't real, but I don't know if we need formulas either, because they aren't true.

Love is insane. Love is ridiculous. Love is real life.

Peace,

Ben

Ben Howard is an accidental iconoclast and generally curious individual living in Nashville, Tennessee. He is also the editor-in-chief of On Pop Theology and an avid fan of waving at strangers for no reason. You can follow him on Twitter @BenHoward87. 
 
You can follow On Pop Theology on Twitter @OnPopTheology or like us on Facebook at www.facebook.com/OnPopTheology.

You might also like:
 

Friday, November 2, 2012

Finding A God I Dismissed

by Ben Howard

Last night the young adult group at my church had a conversation about God. We talked about images of God, and how those images are at their essence analogies that ultimately fall short of who God is. We talked about the historical kataphatic and apophatic traditions that hold differing views on whether or not you can or cannot say anything about God at all.

One of the questions we worked through were the different images of God with an emphasis on the images we gravitate towards. Images of God as father, king, creator, mother, Lord were all mentioned. These are the typical responses. If you went to church you learned how to speak of God early and these were the kinds of things you learned.

As I thought about these images during the conversation it became clear to me that I'm much more comfortable with the regal images of God than I am with the personal or relational images. I'm far more comfortable with calling God king or Lord than I am with images like friend, father or mother.

These are all images that assume some distance from God, but it's not the distance that attracts me, it's the importance. I'm attracted by the breadth and power and authority of these images of God, and its a power and authority I don't attribute to an image of God as friend.

Even more, I'm drawn to the apophatic tradition which says that God is so big, so beyond comprehension that we can't say anything about God at all. In fact, when we try to encounter God the only thing we can do is be silent.

I'm drawn to these images of God and this version of God because they emphasize the power and awesomeness of God and allow me to experience and become familiar with humility. At the same time, it makes me feel like I'm a part of something much bigger.

However, as the conversation continued, I realized that I've been too quick to dismiss some of these relational images of God and that this dismissal has been to my detriment. See, I've always viewed this kind of God as friend thing as being a little schmaltzy and over the top. I think I was only familiar with this image being exploited into the Jesus-is-my-boyfriend language of evangelical teenage girls and proto-love song style worship music. It felt demeaning to God to make him into my friend.

But I think I overreacted. The helpful aspect of this God as friend or father or mother or brother image is that it allows us to connect to God. Prayer, for instance, becomes much easier when you view God as being close to you rather than being a king of a throne. It's dangerous to ask a king something, it's honest to ask your friend.

I've always had a hard time with that kind of personal, relational connection to God. I've always felt uncomfortable praying and talking to God. It's not a question of whether or not he's listening, it's a question of importance.

Let me tell you a story to explain. A few years ago I had a friend who was going through a lot of emotional and personal turmoil. We talked a lot and she shared her frustrations and problems with me on a regular basis. They were serious issues and weighty topics that required being taken seriously. Then I would share my problems, which were typically small relating to some crush I had or a minor frustration in my personal or work life.

My problems always felt less important and I always felt ridiculous talking about them. They didn't matter and when I let these small problems get to me it made me feel bad for letting such small things bother me when someone else close to me was dealing with such significant issues.

Thankfully, my friend was compassionate and always made me comfortable about feeling my own pain and problems. She would remind me that we weren't competing to see whose problems were worse. Even though her issues and frustrations were more serious, it was still okay to feel my feelings.

I want to be more comfortable with that in relationship to God. I want all of us to be more comfortable with that. It's still vitally important to remember the powerful and authoritative images and it's probably even more important to remember that God is bigger than any of these images and is even bigger than we can possibly imagine. However, we still need to remember the closeness of God.

One last point. I want you to notice where I came upon this insight. I wasn't in my room doing my personal devotional reading. I wasn't sitting alone at my house. I wasn't at a party with a bunch of people. I was with friends who I love and trust talking about things that matter deeply to us. I was being honest with them about things I apparently hadn't been honest with myself about. This is the necessity of intentional community. It allows us to love, be loved, and discover things that we would never have discovered otherwise.

Being alone is healthy, having fun with friends and strangers is healthy, but sometimes to learn the lessons that we need to learn, we need to spend some time with people we trust talking about things that make us uncomfortable. That's community. That's the church.

Peace,
Ben

You can follow Ben on Twitter @BenHoward87 or email him at benjamin.howard87 [at] gmail.com.

Also, you can subscribe to On Pop Theology via RSS feed or email on the top right corner of the main page.

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Heaven and How I Met Your Mother



by Ben Howard

Last night my friend and I ended up watching the season premiere of How I Met Your Mother on CBS. If you’re unfamiliar, How I Met Your Mother, or HIMYM, is a sitcom entering it’s eighth season. The narrative catch of the show is that the protagonist, Ted Mosby is telling his future children the story of how he met their mother. The story is set in the present, but the narrator and his kids are set in the future about 20 years.

Different reviewers and critics have termed it a love story in reverse, or a love story wrapped in a mystery. I simply find it entertaining…or infuriating. It really depends on where the story goes.

You see the problem with a show based around a mysterious identity is that it can only tease out that mysterious identity for so long until that tease just becomes annoying. HIMYM has been carrying out that tease for seven years plus one episode at this point and its been pretty annoying since about season three.

However, I almost always enjoy the show when it focuses on its five main characters and their lives. Whether it’s how they interact, or how they deal with the problems of transitioning from twenty-something dreamers to a life with families and careers, I enjoy it. On some level the show connects to the reality of the my situation as a twenty-something who is a little apprehensive about the idea of families and careers and growing up.

As a single man, the frustration over not finding “that mysterious someone” connects to me as well. However, much like the show, I find that when I become overly focused on this kind of end goal, when I believe that the idea of finding “the one” will somehow be the pinnacle of my existence, things aren’t nearly as enjoyable or fulfilling.

I don’t think this just parallels my life or the lives of others in my generation, I think it also parallels the different focuses of the church and it affects people's faith.

A lot of churches focus on the goal of heaven, or if they aren’t so polite about it, they focus on hell. I understand why you would want to focus on that. Happily ever after sounds terrific, especially on the really hard days when nothing makes sense and everything feels hopeless. I understand wanting to jump to the end of the story, but on the other hand I think it misses so much.

The best parts of HIMYM have not been the parts associated with Ted’s search for his future wife. The best parts have been the bizarre moments of life together in community in the present. The best parts have included watching Marshall and Lily get married, or watching Barney develop into a nearly passable human being, or learning about Robin’s past as a Canadian pop singer.

Some of those moments in community have been painful, some have been ridiculous, but they have all been together, in community, in the here and now. The show's very premise is that these moments are part of the story of how Ted met the mother of his children, part of how he became who he needed to be.

In the same way, these moments of community that we experience in the present are part of the story of how we come to embrace heaven and resurrection and redemption. Real life is not a waiting room, it is an essential part of the journey filled with growth and love and pain and laughter.


If we only focus on the end of the story, then the present becomes little more than a frustrating reminder of what has not yet come. However, if we focus on the present, then the future can emerge in its full beauty without the weight of our exasperation and expectation.

Do I hope for resurrection, redemption, and the coming Kingdom of God? Of course! But until it comes, I will love my friends and family and enjoy growing into the person I will be in that hoped for future.

Peace,
Ben

When he isn’t writing about the value of not focusing on the mother in HIMYM, Ben is really really hoping that they’ll just reveal the mother already. It’s been 8 years! I need more than a yellow umbrella! You can follow him on Twitter @BenHoward87 or email him at benjamin.howard87 [at] gmail.com.

Also, you can subscribe to On Pop Theology via RSS feed or email on the top right corner of the main page.

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Shoulder Punching, Obscenities and Cancer

on pop theology, philosophy, theology, culture, pop culture, christianityby Ben Howard


The film 50/50 focuses on a young 20-something named Will Reiser (Joseph Gordon Levitt) and his struggle with cancer and how it changes his everyday life and his view on friends, love and family. It’s easy to focus on the main character of this movie, he’s the hero, he’s the one who overcomes cancer, but I’m more intrigued by the supporting characters and what they show us about how to treat people going through devastating moments in their lives. In particular, I want to focus on Will’s girlfriend Rachael (Bryce Dallas Howard) and his best friend Kyle (Seth Rogen).

Our natural instinct in a situation like this, a tragedy in the life of a friend, is to play the role of the savior. We swallow our pain and assert our strong stoic exterior. Often it feels like their pain is more important than ours and as a result we no longer express our emotions in a truthful way.   

This is the tack taken by Rachael. Will offers her an opportunity to leave the relationship, but she can’t take it even though later events will make it obvious that she wants to go. This is natural, we don’t want to leave because we want to be the kind of person who can withstand the trauma and the heartache of a tragedy. We want to be the kind of people who can be relied on. We have to be strong, and strong people don’t crack, they don’t break. Until they do.

Eventually, Will discovers that Rachael has been cheating on him and breaks up with her. She vents because he doesn’t understand how difficult it’s been for her. She’s right and he doesn’t, but it’s because she would not allow it. We don’t do those we love any favors when we pretend to have strength we don’t have and pretend we don’t feel things that we really do. Honesty and authenticity are vital.

On the other hand we have Kyle. At points in the movie, Kyle comes across as an immature child and a miserable excuse for a best friend. However, the movie comes to affirm that this is kind of the point.  Kyle IS an immature child, and at times he IS a miserable excuse for a best friend, and he treats Will the exact same regardless of his illness. He treats Will like a person instead of a disease. Sean Burns of the Philadelphia Weekly wrote that Kyle’s, “fundamental, unexpected decency, which can often only be expressed through shoulder-punching obscenities, grows more quietly moving as the picture wears on.”

He isn’t perfect and he often acts out of his own selfish reasoning, but he doesn’t change who he is. Near the end of the movie, we discover that Kyle’s character has been reading a book about supporting a friend going throw cancer, in a quick shot of the book we realize that one of the passages underlined simply says, “Be There.”

I think this is at the crux of dealing with tragedy and dealing with pain. We want to fix things so badly, we want to make things better, we want to provide comfort and explanations when there are none available, but the more I think about it the more I believe that we just need to be there even if that’s just shoulder-punching and obscenities.

Peace,
Ben

You can contact me on Twitter @BenHoward87, via email or just leave a comment. Recommendations and guest posts are always appreciated.

Thursday, May 31, 2012

Making Friends with Monsters

on pop theology, philosophy, theology, culture, pop culture, christianityby Ben Howard


Two summers ago something spectacular happened.  Something mind-blowing that changed my life and the way I viewed the world.  It made food taste better, drinks more refreshing, and hugs felt like two hugs given at the same time! Two summers ago I watched the entire series run of Buffy the Vampire Slayer.  Now it would be entirely possible for me to write a book on the meaning of Buffy, and I know people who have done just that, but I want to look at this wonderful show and especially the amazing lead character in the light of creator Joss Whedon’s most recent work, The Avengers, and my favorite character from that movie, Bruce Banner aka the Incredible Hulk.

One of the running themes throughout Buffy the Vampire Slayer is the weight of responsibility on the main characters shoulders.  In show, Buffy is tasked with defending the fictional town of California from all the demons and vampires which congregate there.  This is actually quite a large population since the town, Sunnydale, is located directly above the entrance to Hell.  The most interesting aspect of the series to me is the relationship between Buffy and her friends and family.  Due to the dangers posed by the unruly lot of supernatural creatures and her own belief that she is destined to die (as all in her occupation eventually do), Buffy continually attempts to withdrawal from those close to her.  However, in spite of the peril that if often places them in, her friends continue to support her and do their best to protect her.  Occasionally, they are injured, and in a few cases, they die, but the bonds of friendship and community are more than enough for them to confront not only the vampires and demons of Sunnydale, but also to overcome the barriers Buffy tries to throw in their paths.

Whedon has written a similar character in the form of Bruce Banner.  Due to his proclivity of turning into a large green rage monster, Banner has isolated himself from the world of those he loves and of those who desire to be close to him.  Even when he is brought into the group of Avengers, Banner feels as if he is an outcast of some kind and a danger to all those around him.  Much like Buffy, he feels that his situation in life has made him a ticking time bomb, death and destruction will follow in his wake.  In the movie, Banner is embraced by the witty, occasionally reckless playboy of Tony Stark/Ironman.  Stark appreciates Banner’s intelligence and as the movie progresses their relationship grows.  Stark also finds redeeming qualities in Banner’s inner-monster and their relationship allows Banner to alter his curse into his strength as a superhero.  Instead of being a danger to all of those close to him, he can become their champion and their salvation.

This idea of friendship and love is a powerful one.  The idea that people will love us in spite of the dangers and pain and suffering that our life brings along with it.  And not only will they love us through this suffering, but their love and support will chase us down when we try to flee from them.  There is an idea prevalent in our society that we, as individuals, choose to be part of a community, but perhaps it is the community that chooses us.  Perhaps it is the community that refuses to let us go, even though it would protect them from the pain we may inflect upon them.  Buffy’s friends love her and stay with her even though monsters threaten them at every turn, and Stark stands by Banner and helps him to harness the monster within.  One can only hope that our communities stand by us as we battle our own demons and work with us to overcome them and turn them into strengths, and that we in turn will refuse to let our friends fade away into their own turmoil.  Friends don’t let friends go through it alone.

Peace,
Ben

P.S. Back to the Future! Tonight! 7 pm!  St. B’s!